Planning Citation Analysis Update

The database of Planning faculty was recently updated from planning department websites. This means that faculty rosters are more current than those used in the 2015 Citation Analysis, which was derived from the 2014 ACSP Guide to Undergraduate and Graduate Education in Urban and Regional Planning.  In addition, the database now includes all ACSP and Association of Canadian University Planning Programs (ACUPP).  Check out the new searchable database at:  As you will see, the program rankings have changed significantly.  A complete update will be available in January 2017.

Ranking of Planning Schools based on the median number of Google Scholar citations


Posted in Citation analysis, planning, publications | Leave a comment

Five Academic Planners You Should Know

In his “Research You Can Use” column in Planning magazine, Reid Ewing at the University of Utah, discusses some findings from my 2015 citation analysis of urban planning scholars.  You can read the column here and search the data at:

Posted in Citation analysis, planning, publications | Leave a comment

Where Do the Top Planning Scholars Come From?

My recent analyses of the 2015 citation data considered the school where urban planning faculty are currently teaching.  In a 2013 Planetizen article, I looked at where planning faculty received their degrees, which showed many of these schools did not have urban planning programs.   The following looks at citation activity by degree granting school and current rank.  For 2015, Texas A&M, UIUC, University of Wisconsin, Madison, and UCSB have the highest median citation rates for Assistant, Associate, Full, and all professors, respectively.  To be included schools needed to have a minimum of five faculty in a category.  See Tables 1 through 4 below for the results.

Table 1.  Assistant Professors


Table 2.  Associate Professors


Table 3.  Full Professors


Table 4.  All Professors


Posted in Citation analysis, planning, publications | Leave a comment

Another Way to Slice the Data: Performance by Rank

To control for departments with more senior faculty that have higher citation rates, I used the median number of citations for ranking purposes (see 2015 rankings).  As might be expected, there is significant skewness in the data, attributable to a small number of highly cited faculty.  Another way to compare planning departments is to show rankings by position (Assistant, Associate, and Full Professors).  Because planning faculties are relatively small, I excluded schools with less than three faculty at any particular rank, and I also used the mean instead of the median to show central tendency.  The three tables below show these results.

Table 1.  Assistant Professors


Table 2.  Associate Professors


Table 3.  Full Professors


Posted in Citation analysis, planning, publications | Leave a comment

2015 Urban Planning Citation Analysis

The following is a summary of the 2015 citation analysis results for Urban Planning faculty in North America (mostly U.S.). The lists of urban planning departments and faculty were based on the 20th Edition (2014-2015 academic year) Association of Collegiate Schools of Planning (ACSP) Guide to Undergraduate and Graduate Education in Urban and Regional Planning. Results for 2013 and 2014 describe the methodology (click years to see previous analyses). A recent article in the Journal of Planning Education and Research (JPER) provides in-depth background on the objectives and overall approach (go to article).

Table 1 shows the top 25 planning schools based on the median number of Google Scholar citations per faculty member (this includes only departments with a minimum of 5 tenure-track faculty).  Also, see the department rankings by faculty tenure here.

Table 1


UCLA, Harvard, UC Berkeley, and NYU retain the top 4 spots, with the University of Minnesota moving up from last year to become the fifth most productive planning faculty. New to the top 25 in 2016 are Virginia Tech (19), the University of Pittsburgh (20), University of South Florida (22), and Cornell University (23). These rankings shift slightly from year to year based on changes in faculty rosters (through retirements, new additions, affiliation changes, etc.) ACSP membership, and data adjustments. Additionally, individual faculty citation counts increase each year at varying rates averaging 20-30 percent for tenured faculty (associate and full professors). The total number of citations for current urban planning faculty increased from just under 800,000 in 2014 to over 1,000,000 at the end of 2015. The top 25 cited urban planning faculty are shown in Table 2. The list contains a few changes, most notably the inclusion of Robert Bullard (14), now at Texas Southern University.

Table 2


The data also point to citation thresholds that emerge for the three ranks (Assistant Professor, Associate Professor, and Full Professor). Figure 1 shows the mean and median values for each rank. The middle range of citations for Assistant Professors is about 70, with nearly 300 for Associate Professors, and just over 900 for Full Professors. This corresponds with median years of experience at 7, 15, and 30 years respectively. There is a significant amount of variation within each rank with years of experience (years since terminal degree was received) explaining only about 6 percent of the variation in individual citation activity. Related to my analysis posted in October 2015, there is no statistical difference in citation activity between female and male urban planning faculty for ACSP member schools.

Figure 1


*Note: A tool to query the data for individual faculty and departments will be available soon.

Posted in Citation analysis | 6 Comments

Scholarly Citation Differences Between Male and Female Faculty in U.S. Planning Schools

Among urban planning faculty in the U.S, who is cited more – men or women? My previous analyses compared schools, years of service, and academic rank (see 2014 Urban Planning Citation Analysis), and I thought it would be interesting to look at citation totals by gender. Others have examined these differences noting challenges faced by females due to discrimination and time-off for maternity leave (see for example Leahey, 2006; van Arensbergen, van der Weijden, & Van den Besselaar, 2012). Productivity and citation activity can also be impacted by taking on administrative roles, teaching and advising loads, and other appointments that effect the amount of time available for publishing. Unfortunately data about these activities were not available for individual planning faculty in my sample. The table below shows the median number of citations by rank and gender which includes 291 females and 623 males.

Median Number of Citations by Rank and Gender

Source: Google Scholar

The table shows that there are proportionally larger differences between males and females at the assistant and full professor ranks with slightly less difference for associate professors. However, a statistical test of median values comparing gender and rank suggests there is no significant difference (at 90% confidence level).


So who is cited more?  There appears to be no difference.


Leahey, E. (2006). Gender differences in productivity research specialization as a missing link. Gender & Society, 20(6), 754-780.

van Arensbergen, P., van der Weijden, I., & Van den Besselaar, P. (2012). Gender differences in scientific productivity: a persisting phenomenon? Scientometrics, 93(3), 857-868.

Posted in Citation analysis | 1 Comment

Highway Trust Fund Running Out


Authorization for the federal transportation Highway Trust Fund is set to expire July 31st.  It’s the 34th time in six years that congress has faced this dilemma. If congress does not act… Federal funds for transportation projects will disappear.


Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

TechniCity Enrolls Students from Around the World

TechniCity, the MOOC about cities and technology taught by UAP Professor Tom Sanchez and Ohio State University Professor Jennifer Evans-Cowley, enrolled 9,355 students from 154 countries.  Nearly 40% of students enrolled are from emerging economies around the world. The following summarize characteristics of students enrolled in the course.





Posted in MOOCs | Tagged , | 1 Comment

Seattle Public Transit Reacts To Income Inequality

This weekend, the Seattle metro area launched an initiative to address income inequality through public transit. People in low-income households can now ride buses, trains and ferries at reduced fares.

The initiative is among the first of its kind in the U.S., and transit experts across the country are watching closely. Thomas Sanchez, a professor of urban affairs and planning at Virginia Tech, discusses the initiative with Here & Now’s Jeremy Hobson.

Posted in equity | Tagged | Leave a comment

Excellent TechniCity 2014 Student Projects

The following are the top 20+ student projects as selected by the TechniCity instructors.  There were many, many great projects overall!  Click on the title to read more about the project.  See the 2013 projects here.

Author(s) Project
Agnieszka Szczepańska Biking in Warsaw
Alessandra Manganelli, Brian Channel, Tal Ashkenazi Enhancing, sharing, and protecting urban green spaces
J. Álvarez-Vidales, M.J. Perea-Medina, and A. Cerezo-Medina Tourist flows management in Málaga
Brittany Kubinski Intersection safety
Dani Ne’eman Improving traffic light effectiveness
Dursun Yildirim Bayar Augmented reality for urban tourism
Eartha Barclay Community action app
Eric Gould Bike lane lighting
Giulia Volla Platform for community engagement
Giuseppe Lassandro Private bicycle mobility
Janos Katona and Ilaria Meggetto Green Urban Landscape Proximity Index
Jessica Hyegyung Kim Engage with your city park
Kanika Sharma “Raise the Issue” App
Marques Anderson Piezoelectric flooring
Mhd Amer Al Zeiback The World Heritage City of Damascus
Miao Zhou “Hail a Taxi in Beijing” app
Michalina Gamification and energy use
Neelakshi Joshi SuperForager: edibles app
Samantha Jones SuperForager: edibles app
Yari Sanfelice Flood monitoring in Florence, Italy
Ashley Carpenter Free Columbus Project
Jerry Huang Smart district energy
Kurt Allebach Augmented reality for situational awareness
Magali Rombola Citizen data collection app
Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | Leave a comment